path: root/UKRAINE.md

# Ukraine, Russia, and a World Tragedy

## Updated message for October 6, 2024

Остановите безумие. Закончить войну. Верни ребят домой.

Two and a half years on, the war in Europe continues, at great cost to the peoples of both
Ukraine and Russia. Hundreds of thousands of casualities, perhaps even millions, on both
sides of the conflict, for two peoples that quite recently considered themselves as brothers and sisters.

How to make it stop? The solution to this problem is simple.

As the aggressor, Russia must merely recall its forces from Ukraine, and end its
invasion, returning to the borders as they were drawn over 30 years ago. It must give
up its imperial ambitions.

Ukraine must of course recall its forces from Russia as well.

And both sides must commit to a ceasation of hostilities.

It is not reasonable to expect Ukraine to do so first or unilaterally, while Russian forces
occupy some 20% of its territory. Russia is the clear aggressor here, for reasons that defy
explanation. The original goals ("denazification") were themselves laughable, particularly given
that many of the invading Russian forces were self-styled neo-nazis.

And now? To fight NATO?
To fight the USA? To what end?

Only Russia can make this war end, and if the current Russian leaership is unwilling to
do so, then it is up to the Russian people -- the mothers and fathers and wives and
siblings of those who are losing life and limb fighting a war that makes no sense to anyone
-- to resolve the matter in other ways.

Or shall the Russian people continue to led by a madman who so clearly perceives
himself as a 21st century reincarnation of Stalin (whether he publicly admits so or not?)

- Garrett D'Amore

My original message, from over two years ago, is retained below.

## A message to those inside Russia

### Written March 4, 2022.

It is with a very heavy heart that I write this. I am normally opposed to the use of open source
projects to communicate political positions or advocate for things outside the immediate relevancy
to that project.

However, the events occurring in Ukraine, and specifically the unprecedented invasion of Ukraine by
Russian forces operating under orders from Russian President Vladimir Putin compel me to speak out.

Those who know me, know that I have family, friends, and colleagues in Russia, and Ukraine both. My closest friends
have historically been Russian friends my wife's hometown of Chelyabinsk. I myself have in the past
frequently traveled to Russia, and indeed operated a software development firm with offices in St. Petersburg.
I had a special kinship with Russia and its people.

I say "had", because I fear that the actions of Putin, and the massive disinformation campaign that his regime
has waged inside Russia, mean that it's likely that I won't see those friends again. At present, I'm not sure
my wife will see her own mother again. We no longer feel it's safe for either of us to return Russia given
actions taken by the regime to crack down on those who express disagreement.

Russian citizens are being led to believe it is acting purely defensively, and that only legitimate military
targets are being targeted, and that all the information we have received in the West are fakes.

I am confident that nothing could be further from the truth.

This has caused many in Russia, including people whom I respect and believe to be smarter than this, to
stand by Putin, and endorse his actions. The claim is that the entirety of NATO is operating at the behest
of the USA, and that the entirety of Europe was poised to attack Russia. While this is clearly absurd to those
of us with any understanding of western politics, Russian citizens are being fed this lie, and believing it.

If you're reading this from inside Russia -- YOU are the person that I hope this message reaches. Your
government is LYING to you. Of course, all governments lie all the time. But consider this. Almost the
entire world has condemned the invasion of Ukraine as criminal, and has applied sanctions. Even countries
which have poor relations with the US sanctioning Russia, as well as nations which historically have remained
neutral. (Famously neutral -- even during World War II, Switzerland has acted to apply sanctions in
concert with the rest of the world.)

Ask yourself, why does Putin fear a free press so much, if what he says is true? Why the crack-downs on
children expressing only a desire for peace with Ukraine? Why would the entire world unified against him,
if Putin was in the right? Why would the only countries that stood with Russia against
the UN resolution to condemn these acts as crimes be Belarus, North Korea, and Syria? Even countries normally
allied to Russia could not bring themselves to do more than abstain from the vote to condemn it.

To be clear, I do not claim that the actions taken by the West or by the Ukrainian government were completely
blameless. On the contrary, I understand that Western media is biased, and the truth is rarely exactly
as reported. I believe that there is a kernel of truth in the claims of fascists and ultra-nationalist
militias operating in Ukraine and specifically Donbas. However, I am also equally certain that Putin's
response is out of proportion, and that concerns about such militias are principally just a pretext to justify
an invasion.

Europe is at war, unlike we've seen in my lifetime. The world is more divided, and closer to nuclear holocaust
than it has been since the Cold War. And that is 100% the fault of Putin.

While Putin remains in power, there cannot really be any way for Russian international relations to return
to normal. Putin has set your country on a path to return to the Cold War, likely because he fancies himself
to be a new Stalin. However, unlike the Soviet Union, the Russian economy does not have the wherewithal to
stand on its own, and the invasion of Ukraine has fully ensured that Russia will not find any friends anywhere
else in Europe, and probably few places in Asia.

The _only_ paths forward for Russia are either a Russia without Putin (and those who would support his agenda),
or a complete breakdown of Russian prosperity, likely followed by the increasing international conflict that will
be the natural escalation from a country that is isolated and impoverished. Those of us observing from the West are
gravely concerned, because we cannot see any end to this madness that does not result in nuclear conflict,
unless from within.

In the meantime, the worst prices will be paid for by innocents in Ukraine, and by young Russian men
forced to carry out the orders of Putin's corrupt regime.

And _that_ is why I write this -- to appeal to those within Russia to open your eyes, and think with
your minds. It is right and proper to be proud of your country and its rich heritage. But it is also
right and proper to look for ways to save it from the ruinous path that its current leadership has set it upon,
and to recognize when that leadership is no longer acting in interest of the country or its people.

- Garrett D'Amore, March 4, 2022

### Updates on March 16, 2024:

I've made some minor typographical fixes.

It is extremely distressing to see that two years on, the
people of both Ukraine and Russia continue to suffer under this needless, pointless, conflict fought solely to assuage
the ego of a dictator.

The actions done here, have killed thousands, probably hundreds of thousands, of soldiers and civilians alike, and there seems to be no end to the madness. I still pray for sanity to return, because the current path, if followed
to its logical conclusion, most likely ends in apocalypse.

If you find my sharing these truths uncomfortable, please feel welcome to cease use of my software. While the license does permit use by anyone for any reason, I would not be displeased if the Russian military, and those sympathetic to it, declined from use of any of my work.